The following priests have served as pastors of St. Mary's Church:
Thomas A. Maher (1868-1869)
Myles J. Laughlin, D.D. (1869-1877)
William E. Mulheron (1877-1913)
William F. Payne (1913-25)
John J. McGrath (1925-1932)
William E. Cowen, S.T.D. (1932-61)
James D. Cuffney (1961-79)
Edward A. Zimmer (1979-1992)
Robert J. Schrader (1992-2004)
Frank E. Lioi (2004- )
The following priests have served as assistant pastors at St. Mary's Church:
Rev. Dr. Massan
Rev. Dr. Lynch
Eugene Pagani
W. Thurston
J.H. Russell
William Morrin
J.H. Connolly
Max Casimir
Joseph hendricks
John Donnelly
George V. Burns
F.J. Burns
James H. Day
James Hickey
F.J. Burns
John J. McGrath
Joseph P. Quinn
John F. O'Hern
James J. Gibbons
John B. Doran
John R. Fitzsimmons
E.J. Dwyer
S.J. Byrne
Patrick J. Smyth
Arthur LeMay
Daniel Quigley
Victor J. Hurley
Charles E. Muckle
Raymond Quigley
Samuel J. Houghton
Rt. Rev. Francis B. Burns
John P. O'Beirne
John M. Ball
Leo Mooney
George Macauley
Joseph Margrett
Timothy J. McGrath
Armand Benoit (Albany)
Robert H. Fennessy
J. Joseph O'Connell
William D. Tobin
Walter Carron
Ralph Meyer
Rt. Rev. Leslie G. Whalen
Joseph McNamara
Paul J. Lynch
Charles L. McCarthy
Robert J. Downs
Robert G. Smith
Charles irwin Sullivan
Edwin B. Metzger
Guy J. Wertz
William Cosgrove
Gerald J. Guli
Robert L. Kress
Arthur J. Hack
Ignatius St. George
Rt. Rev. James D. Cuffney
Most Rev. Dennis W. Hickey, D.D.
Edwin Agonis, O.M.C.
Richard C. Tormey
E. Leo McManus
John F. White (Archdiocese of New York)
Charles Langworthy
John Patrick Norris
James C. Enright
Anthony valenti
David Gramkee
Robert J. Kanka
Bernard Casper *
Robert T. Werth
Joseph Catanise
Thomas Corbett
David Faraone
Patrick Guiany Sullivan
Lee P. Chase
John D. Dillon
Steven Lape
B. Munjala Wakhungu
